Search
Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
An inviting shaded Sarasota neighborhood restaurant patio with woven chairs, wood cafe tables and lush subtropical planting.

The Old Knick's Tavern Corner Is Getting a New Kitchen From the Pub Next Door

November 12, 2026

Since 2002, 1818 S. Osprey Ave. has been a place to eat, first as Knick's Tavern & Grill and later as The 1818 Grill. Next door at 1816, Legends Sports Pub runs on a beer and wine license and has no food menu. This fall the two traded roles. The address that always served dinner went dark after its last service on Saturday, Sept. 26, and the bar that never cooked is buying the business with plans to become a full bar and restaurant, the Sarasota Herald-Tribune reported.

That swap sums up Southside Village this fall. The shake-up on the 1800 block of S. Osprey and along Hillview Street has been real, and most of what fills the gaps comes from people already tied to the block: a neighbor expanding, a Sarasota native who spent years waiting for a storefront here, and owners rebuilding or reworking spaces they already hold. For the people who walk to Southside Village from Cherokee Park, Harbor Acres and the streets west of the Trail, this season's lineup is mostly the same operators in new positions.

A Summer Off-Season Priced Out the Prime Rib

Tommy Lovell took over the Knick's space in 2024 and later renamed it The 1818 Grill. When he spoke to the Herald-Tribune about closing, he blamed an especially tough off-season in the Sarasota area this summer, plus the rising cost of gas, produce, cooking oil and beef.

The clearest sign of that pressure was a menu item. The Friday and Saturday prime rib dinners had sold for about $37 to $40, and keeping the margin would have pushed the plate close to $50. He told the paper:

"I couldn't justify a $50 prime rib dinner to try and make a little bit of money off that. My prime rib dinners were always around $37, $40, and I just didn't want to give that to the customer, so I stopped doing prime rib on Friday and Saturday nights."

The gap between $40 and $50 is the margin a neighborhood grill depends on. A dining room that fills in February and empties in August has to make the whole year's numbers work, and this summer they stopped working at 1818.

The Buyer Was Already Next Door

The sale is not going to an outside group. Lovell told the paper he is selling the business to the Siciliano family, who own Legends Sports Pub at 1816 S. Osprey. Their plan is to turn the former Grill into a full bar and restaurant, which would give Legends the kitchen and broader license it lacks today.

On the sidewalk, this means the corner where Knick's served food for more than two decades will stay a place to eat and drink, now run by the people who have been pouring beer next to it. The menu, hours and look are the Sicilianos' to set. The use stays the same.

Across the Street, a Two-Year Search Ended at 1817

Directly across S. Osprey, the newest storefront came from a resident too. The Red Thread Atelier opened on Sept. 12 at 1817 S. Osprey Ave., according to the Herald-Tribune. Founder Vaughn Dorrian is a fourth-generation Floridian who grew up in Sarasota. She opened her first needlepoint shop in Locust Valley, New York, in 2023, and she told the paper she looked for a space in this part of town for more than two years.

The size gap between the two shops explains the plan. The New York shop measured 400 square feet. The Sarasota shop is 1,420, more than three times larger, and Dorrian wants the extra room to serve as a community third space, with weekly stitching nights and art classes ranging from seashell decorating to watercolor.

"Southside Village is a unique shopping district that has really blossomed and turned into a great little area," she told the Herald-Tribune.

She opened that 1,420-square-foot bet on S. Osprey two weeks before The 1818 Grill served its last dinner across the street.

Alma de España Left for a Building Its Chef's Company Bought

The one departure that took a restaurant off the block still kept it local. Alma de España, the Spanish restaurant from chef-owner Elier Rodriguez, closed at 1830 S. Osprey Ave. on Sept. 30 and spent October readying a new location at 239 S. Links Ave. downtown. Your Observer reported that the roughly 1,100-square-foot property sold for $1.65 million on Sept. 28 to Cathedral Hospitality Holdings LLC, which is registered to Rodriguez, and that the restaurant set its grand opening there for Nov. 1.

The Links Avenue building has its own history. It was home to Indigenous, chef Steve Phelps's restaurant, which closed in mid-September after 15 years. The Herald-Tribune called that the hardest loss of a rough September for Sarasota dining.

So the Southside Village kitchen that left stayed in Sarasota, headed for one of downtown's best-known dining rooms in a building owned by its chef's company. The menu Rodriguez planned for Links Avenue runs from gazpacho to paella to flan and reflects Spain and Cuba, where he was born and raised. He trained at Le Cordon Bleu in Atlanta and spent two years at Picasso inside the Bellagio in Las Vegas. For anyone who ate at 1830 S. Osprey, his cooking is now a drive downtown rather than a walk up Osprey.

Pacific Rim, the Hillview Fixture Since 1998

The rebuild that matters most on Hillview Street is a restaurant being restored by its own owner. Pacific Rim, at 1859 Hillview St., has been part of Southside Village since 1998. It is a family-run Japanese-Thai restaurant known for sushi, curries, pad Thai and drunken noodles, and for playing 50 Cent's "In Da Club" when birthday desserts come out. A fire on Saturday, July 18, closed it, Sarasota Magazine reported.

Owner Veth Senenoi gave the magazine Nov. 15 as his goal, without a firm date. When Pacific Rim returns, he plans to make some changes and work in the kitchen as chef for as long as a year. "I want to make sure everything comes out perfectly," he told Sarasota Magazine.

The neighborhood showed up fast. A GoFundMe started by a friend of the owners was close to $91,000 at the time of that report, and supporters pointed regulars toward Bangkok Restaurant Sarasota, which they described as Pacific Rim's sister restaurant. The restaurant's Facebook page and Instagram are where the owners post updates.

Last Fall's Precedent Sits at 1920 Hillview

This is not the first time the block has handled a closing this way. In August 2025, Adeline's co-owners, chef Drew Adams and restaurateur Edward Zaki, said their special-occasion restaurant at 1920 Hillview St. would close in early October of that year. The Herald-Tribune reported that Zaki pointed to seasonal traffic, slow weekdays and summer heat, and planned to turn the leased space into something more approachable.

That space became Mimi's Brasserie & Speakeasy, which opened in early December 2025, according to Sarasota Magazine.

A year apart, the same seasonal pressure that pushed Adeline to change formats closed The 1818 Grill. Both times, the answer came from someone already holding a key on the block.

Where Each Address Stands This Week

For anyone walking the village before season fills the sidewalks:

  • 1816 S. Osprey Ave. Legends Sports Pub, run by the Siciliano family, is buying the business next door and plans a full bar and restaurant there.
  • 1817 S. Osprey Ave. The Red Thread Atelier, Vaughn Dorrian's needlepoint shop, open since Sept. 12, with weekly stitching nights and art classes planned.
  • 1818 S. Osprey Ave. The former Knick's Tavern & Grill and 1818 Grill, closed since Sept. 26 and set to become part of Legends.
  • 1830 S. Osprey Ave. Vacated by Alma de España on Sept. 30.
  • 239 S. Links Ave., downtown. Alma de España's new location in the former Indigenous building, bought by a company registered to its chef.
  • 1859 Hillview St. Pacific Rim, rebuilding after the July 18 fire, with Veth Senenoi planning to cook when it reopens.
  • 1920 Hillview St. Mimi's Brasserie & Speakeasy, in the former Adeline space since December 2025.

Of the seven addresses, one storefront is waiting for its next tenant. The other changes went to an existing neighbor, a returning native or an owner already invested in Southside Village.

If you would like to talk about how Southside Village's corners factor into a home on the surrounding streets, Coastal Reserve is glad to share what we see. Request a confidential consultation.

Follow Us On Instagram